|
“A wonderful book.... In addition to being a first-rate monograph--a
significant contribution to nineteenth-century French studies--it is also a delightful read and a page-turner.” —
Jonathan Beecher, Professor of History, University of California, Santa Cruz
Reviews:
“Clearly,
this is a superb work, one that captures a major moment in French and European thought with thorough scholarship and literary
grace. Highly recommended.” — Choice
“[Hecht] brings wit and enthusiasm to her densely
packed tale of the freethinking anthropologists.” — Nina C. Ayoub, Chronicle of Higher Education
“A
fascinating glimpse of a little-known chapter in French history.” — Publishers Weekly
“Hecht
is…a very good writer and a brilliant researcher. Highly recommended for all academic libraries.” — Library
Journal
“A well-researched, persuasive, and engaging contribution to the cultural history of modern France.” —
John I. Brooks III, Journal of Modern History
“The often poignant life-histories she recounts...are
one of the real pleasures on offer in this wide-ranging, original study of late nineteenth-century French anthropologists.” —
Elizabeth Williams, American Historical Review
“A comprehensively researched, carefully contextualized,
engagingly narrated, and provocatively revelatory book about an underappreciated episode in the history of anthropology and
religion.” — George Stocking, Distinguished Professor in Anthropology, University of Chicago,
Journal of Anthropological Research
“Hecht has given us a very strong account of the republican scientific
vision… This book will be richly rewarding to scholars of the Third Republic, to historians of anti-clericalism and of the
social sciences, and even to laymen with an interest in the current round of the nature-nurture culture wars about the genome
and evolutionary psychology.” — Martin S. Staum, University of Calgary, H-France Book Reviews
“Hecht
is a vivid writer with a keen eye for the evocative anecdote and the unexpected interconnection. … Provocative reading for
historians of science, social science, religion, and republican politics.” — Jean Elisabeth Pedersen, University
of Rochester, Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences
“The book makes a significant contribution
and should be of interest not only to historians but to a wider readership interested in the intersection of culture, science,
and politics…fascinating and far-sighted… Hecht has produced a work of impressive erudition.” — Susan Terrio, Professor
of French and Anthropology at Georgetown University, Anthropological Quarterly
“[A]n important,
challenging, and controversial discussion of French anthropology… Hecht writes in a vigorous and often delightful manner [and]
has explored some fascinating archives.” — Joy Harvey, Isis: The Journal of the History of Science
The
End of the Soul: Scientific Modernity, Atheism, and Anthropology in France, 1876-1936 On October 19, 1876 a group
of leading French citizens, both men and women included, joined together to form an unusual group, The Society of Mutual Autopsy,
with the aim of proving that souls do not exist.The idea was that, after death, they would dissect each other and (hopefully)
show a direct relationship between brain shapes and sizes and the character, abilities and intelligence of individuals. This
strange scientific pact, and indeed what we have come to think of as anthropology, which the group's members helped to develop,
had its genesis in aggressive, evangelical atheism.
With this group as its focus, The End of the Soul is a study
of science and atheism in France in late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. It shows that anthropology grew in the
context of an impassioned struggle between the forces of tradition, especially the Catholic faith, and those of a more freethinking
modernism, and moreover that it became for many a secular religion. Among the adherents of this new faith discussed here are
the novelist Emile Zola, the great statesman Leon Gambetta, the American birth control advocate Margaret Sanger, and Arthur
Conan Doyle, whose Sherlock Holmes embodied the triumph of ratiocination over credulity.
Boldly argued, full of colorful
characters and often bizarre battles over science and faith, this book represents a major contribution to the history of science
and European intellectual history.
Hecht talks about the book and the amazing group it brings
to life in an article on brain research in a past issue of the magazine
Science and Theology News.
The End of the Soul is available
in bookstores and from Columbia University Press. For more information see the CU
Press site or amazon.com.
|